Advertise
Contact
Forms
EEdition
Freeman Courier


  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Obituaries
  • Photos
    • Photos Of The Day
    • Photo Galleries
  • South Dakota News Watch
  • Archives
    • More Archives
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
    • News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Obituaries
    • Photos
      • Photos Of The Day
      • Photo Galleries
    • South Dakota News Watch
    • Archives
      • More Archives
    • About Us
    • Subscribe
EDITORIAL:
Freeman Courier
opinion
By News Staff  
February 7, 2020

EDITORIAL: A Ban on ban is a bad idea

Our opinion: South Dakota lawmakers should vote against a bill that would allow the state to prohibit town and county agencies from setting their own rules about plastic.

If you and your family decide to stop using plastic bags and plastic straws, should the state tell you that you can’t do that? Most people would say, “no, it’s my choice.”

What about the citizens of a city? If a majority of the residents decide to stop using plastic bags and plastic straws in their city, should the state tell them that they can’t do that? Of course not.

But some legislators think so.

Senate Bill 54 would prohibit government entities in South Dakota from adopting ordinances that would ban straws and “auxiliary containers,” which the bill defines as bags, cups, bottles, packages, containers or other packaging made out of cloth, paper, plastic, cardboard, corrugated material, aluminum, glass or recycled material that can either be reusable or single use.

Sen. John Wiik, R-Big Stone City, filed the measure in the 2020 Legislature and 21 legislators have signed on as cosponsors. The Senate Commerce and Energy Committee passed the measure Monday morning on a 4-2 vote, sending it to the floor for action by the full Senate.

This bill actually updates an existing law that says no other city or county can restrict the use of plastic beverage containers, garbage bags or plastic packing materials. The expanded ban would apply to any “local unit of government” – a county, municipality, school district, special district or other political subdivision in the state.

Let’s be clear: this is not about whether banning straws or plastic shopping bags is good for the environment. Some believe it is ecologically responsible to end their use. Some believe that’s ridiculous. Let’s just put that aside for a moment.

The issue is local control; whether a city or county can make that determination for their citizens. Preempting that option runs counter to the concept of self-governance and self-determination.

Put simply, if the city of Freeman, Marion, Menno or Olivet, Hutchinson County or Turner County, concludes that a ban on these products is in the best interest of their residents — whether to protect the environment or cut down on litter — who is the state of South Dakota to tell them they can’t? Undoubtedly, a ban like this would go to a vote of the people. Again, if that’s what the majority of the people in those cities or county want, who is the state of South Dakota to tell them they can’t?

Local control has been a longstanding popular mantra in the South Dakota Legislature. It should apply to this measure as well; legislators should reject SB54.

The Freeman Courier editorial reflects the opinion of publisher Jeremy Waltner and former publisher Tim L. Waltner

Related Posts
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store


Editor’s Picks
Most Read
SAARIE AND HIS STOLEN POLARIS RANGER; THE REPORT
news
SAARIE AND HIS STOLEN POLARIS RANGER; THE REPORT
By Jeremy Waltner 
July 5, 2025
EDITOR'S NOTE: This story will appear in print in the July 9 issue of The Courier. Three individuals have been arrested and are facing state felony ch...
this is a test
ALL IN THE FAMILY
news
ALL IN THE FAMILY
By Jeremy Waltner 
July 1, 2025
Forty-two years ago, his Grandpa Ted took over Ferd’s Market and renamed it Ted’s Market. Ten years after that, his dad, Bob, took over Ted’s Market a...
this is a test
CHISLIC FESTIVAL RETURNING JULY 26; MOVING TO EVERY-OTHER-YEAR FORMAT
news
CHISLIC FESTIVAL RETURNING JULY 26; MOVING TO EVERY-OTHER-YEAR FORMAT
By Jeremy Waltner 
July 14, 2025
The Freeman community and volunteers from the surrounding area — known as “The Chislic Circle” — are once again making plans to welcome thousands to t...
this is a test
PHOTO OF THE DAY: STANDING WATER
photo day
PHOTO OF THE DAY: STANDING WATER
By Jeremy Waltner 
July 8, 2025
Emma Schoenwald and friend Evelyn Lafrentz found enjoyment in a ditch full of water not far north of their Dewald Street homes in Freeman Monday eveni...
this is a test
‘BRIGHT STAR’ NAMED 2026 SCHMECKFEST MUSICAL
news
‘BRIGHT STAR’ NAMED 2026 SCHMECKFEST MUSICAL
By Jeremy Waltner 
July 16, 2025
“Bright Star,” a musical that opened on Broadway in 2016 and was nominated for five Tony Awards, including Best New Musical, has been selected as the ...
this is a test
ePaper
coogle_play
app_store
Freeman Courier

Stay tuned with us

Accessibility Policy
Privacy
Forms

Copyright © Freeman Courier. All rights reserved.